Skip to main content
Home

2018-9

Object Title
Vessel in the form of a seated figure holding a cup ('China')
Measurements
approx. h. 76.2 cm (30 in.)
Creation Date
A.D. 1100-1400
Credit Line
Museum purchase, Peter Jay Sharp, Class of 1952, Fund
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Object URL
https://artmuseum.princeton.edu/collections/objects/133367
Museum's Definition of Antiquity
1532
Provenance Information
By 1967, Alan C. Lapiner, New York; 1967-2018, private New York collection (collector object #92)
Exhibition Information
none
Publication Information
none
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Informed judgement that works were outside of the country of modern discovery before 1970
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
Based on the results of provenance research, the Princeton University Art Museum can make an informed judgment that the object was outside its probable country of modern discovery before 1970. The collector maintained a sequential inventory of their collection with the year of each acquisition specified. The accuracy of the list is corroborated by a number of works in the inventory that were either published in other collections prior to the collector’s acquisition date or published or exhibited shortly after the acquisition, in each instance with the appropriate ownership history indicated. According to the inventory, the collector acquired this work in the second half of 1967.

2018-8

Object Title
Cylinder stamp with supernatural figure
Measurements
h. 6.6 × diam. 5 cm (2 5/8 × 1 15/16 in.)
Creation Date
1000-500 B.C.
Credit Line
Museum purchase, Fowler McCormick, Class of 1921, Fund
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Object URL
https://artmuseum.princeton.edu/collections/objects/133366
Museum's Definition of Antiquity
1532
Provenance Information
1967 (July or later)-2018, private New York collection (collector object #80)
Exhibition Information
none
Publication Information
none
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Informed judgement that works were outside of the country of modern discovery before 1970
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
Based on the results of provenance research, the Princeton University Art Museum can make an informed judgment that the object was outside its probable country of modern discovery before 1970. The collector maintained a sequential inventory of their collection with the year of each acquisition specified. The accuracy of the list is corroborated by a number of works in the inventory that were either published in other collections prior to the collector’s acquisition date or published or exhibited shortly after the acquisition, in each instance with the appropriate ownership history indicated. According to the inventory, the collector acquired this work in the second half of 1967.

2017-244-34

Object Title
Cocoon Jar
Measurements
14 1/4 x 10 15/16 x 16 15/16inches (36.2 x 27.8 x 43cm)
Creation Date
Western Han Dynasty (206 BCE-9 CE), 2nd century BCE - early 1st century CE
Credit Line
125th Anniversary Acquisition. Gift of Ann E. and Donald W. McPhail, 2017
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Provenance Information
With Li En Zhu, Ridgefield, CT; sold to Donald W. McPhail and Ann E. McPhail, Philadelphia, March 28, 1998; gift to PMA, 2017.
Exhibition Information
Philadelphia, Philadelphia Museum of Art, "Gifts in Honor of the 125th Anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art", September 9 - December 11, 2002.
Publication Information
Gifts in honor of the 125th anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art (Philadelphia: Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2002), 3, 167, checklist 10.
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Gift or bequest expected or on loan prior to 2008
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
The donors, Donald and Ann McPhail, signed a gift pledge agreement with the Philadelphia Museum of Art on January 2, 2002.

2017-244-32

Object Title
Tomb Figure: Mounted Lute Player
Measurements
17 5/8 x 5 9/16 x 15 13/16inches (44.8 x 14.1 x 40.2cm)
Creation Date
Late 7th - early 8th century
Credit Line
125th Anniversary Acquisition. Gift of Ann E. and Donald W. McPhail, 2017
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Provenance Information
With E. & J. Frankel, Ltd., New York, by 1997; sold to Donald W. McPhail and Ann E. McPhail, Philadelphia, April 13, 1997; gift to Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2017.
Exhibition Information
Philadelphia, Philadelphia Museum of Art, "Gifts in Honor of the 125th Anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art", September 9 - December 11, 2002.
Publication Information
Gifts in honor of the 125th anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art (Philadelphia: Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2002), 3, 170, checklist 30.
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Gift or bequest expected or on loan prior to 2008
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
The donors, Donald and Ann McPhail, signed a gift pledge agreement with the Philadelphia Museum of Art on January 2, 2002.

2017-244-33

Object Title
Tomb Figure: Mounted Cymbal Player
Measurements
17 7/8 x 5 9/16 x 16 13/16inches (45.4 x 14.1 x 42.7cm)
Creation Date
Late 7th - early 8th century
Credit Line
125th Anniversary Acquisition. Gift of Ann E. and Donald W. McPhail, 2017
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Provenance Information
With E. & J. Frankel, Ltd., New York, by 1997; sold to Donald W. McPhail and Ann E. McPhail, Philadelphia, April 13, 1997; gift to the Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2017.
Exhibition Information
Philadelphia, Philadelphia Museum of Art, "Gifts in Honor of the 125th Anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art", September 9 - December 11, 2002.
Publication Information
Gifts in honor of the 125th anniversary of the Philadelphia Museum of Art (Philadelphia: Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2002), 3, 170, checklist 30.
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Gift or bequest expected or on loan prior to 2008
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
The donors, Donald and Ann McPhail, signed a gift pledge agreement with the Philadelphia Museum of Art on January 2, 2002.

2016-97

Object Title
Vessel portraying inebriated youths
Measurements
h. 16.4 cm., diam. (max) 17.2 cm. (6 7/16 × 6 3/4 in.)
Creation Date
A.D. 550-700
Credit Line
Museum purchase, Mary Trumbull Adams Art Fund
Culture
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Object URL
http://artmuseum.princeton.edu/collections/objects/124819
Museum's Definition of Antiquity
1521
Provenance Information
private collection, California, c. 1965; Robert and Marianne Huber, Chicago (purchased from above owner according to written statement), c. 1965-1969; D. Daniel Michel, Chicago (69:156), 1969-1991; Art of the Ancient New World, New York, 1991; private U.S. collection, 1991-2016; acquired by the Princeton University Art Museum, 2016
Exhibition Information
None
Publication Information
Henderson, Lucia
2008 “Blood, Water, Vomit, and Wine: Pulque in Maya and Aztec Belief,” Mesoamerican Voices 3:53-76. Illus., Fig. 21b (p. 68; line drawing of a detail).

Photographed by Justin Kerr (K9294) and published online at mayavase.com sometime on or after 2006.
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Informed judgement that works were outside of the country of modern discovery before 1970
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
Based on the results of provenance research, the Princeton University Art Museum can make an informed judgment that the object was outside its probable country of modern discovery before 1970. D. Daniel Michel gave each item in his collection a catalogue number, the first two digits of which indicate the year he acquired the work, in this case (19)69. The validity of this cataloguing system is supported by exhibition loans and publications documenting both Michel’s ownership of various items in the appropriate period as well as at least one item published in another collection prior to the date of Michel’s acquisition. Additionally, Robert and Marianne Huber, Chicago, provided a statement that they sold the work to Michel in 1969 after acquiring it from a California collector “in about 1965.”

2017.177

Object Title
Cacao Vase
Measurements
10 x 5-1/4 (diam.) in.
Credit Line
Gift of Michael K. and Patricia 'Polis' McCrory
Culture
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Provenance Information
Purchased in Guatemala by Alfred Stendahl for (Stendahl Galleries, Los Angeles, California) between 1965 and 1972;{1} purchased by Dr. Wally and Brenda Zollman, Indianapolis, Indiana, around about 1980; purchased by Michael and Patricia McCrory, Indianapolis, Indiana, in 1998; given to the Indianapolis Museum of Art at Newfields in 2017.

{1} Alfred Stendahl's collecting activities suggest he purchased the vase between 1965 and 1972. Photography of the vase at Stendahl Galleries dates to 1976.
Exhibition Information
The Face of Ancient America: The Wally and Brenda Zollman Collection of Pre-Columbian Art, Indianapolis Museum of Art, Noyes Gallery, December 03, 1988 to February 26, 1989
Publication Information
Published in the Exhibition Catalogue for 'The Face of Ancient America: The Wally and Brenda Zollman Collection of Pre-Columbian Art'
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Cumulative facts and circumstances
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
The vase belonged to two collectors who have been involved with the IMA for decades. It has appeared in exhibitions and publications by renown archaeologists, Michael D. Coe and Lee Parsons. The object’s provenance in the United States goes back to at least 1972, per the report prepared by the law office of Kate Fitz Gibbon, which states that Stendahl Galleries records indicate acquisition of the vase between 1965 and 1972. It has been on loan to the IMA previously and was included in the IMA 1988 exhibition, “The Face of Ancient America: The Wally and Brenda Zollman Collection of Precolumbian Art,” and was illustrated in the accompanying catalogue.

2015.500.7.9

Object Title
Jar with Painted Decoration of "Frog" Pattern
Measurements
H. 16 1/2 in. (41.9 cm); Diam. 14 in. (35.6 cm); Diam. of rim: 6 1/2 in. (16.5 cm); Diam. of base: 4 1/2 in. (11.4 cm)
Creation Date
ca. 2300–2000 B.C., Neolithic period, Majiayao culture, Machang phase
Credit Line
Gift of Florence and Herbert Irving, 2015
Country of Origin
Object Type
Materials / Techniques
Object URL
http://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/42694
Provenance Information
Purchased from Galaxie Art & Gift Company, Hong Kong, by Florence and Herbert Irving, New
York, in 1988; Collection of Florence and Herbert Irving, New York from 1988 to 2015, on loan to The Metropolitan Museum of Art from 1988 until donation to The Metropolitan Museum of Art in 2015.
Exhibition Information
None
Publication Information
Published on The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s online collection database.
http://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/42694?sortBy=Relevance&ft=2015.500.7.9&offset=0&rpp=20&pos=1 as of July 2015
Section of the AAMD Guidelines relied upon for the exception to 1970
Gift or bequest expected or on loan prior to 2008
Explain why the object fits the exception set forth above
The Jar with Painted Decoration of “Frog” Pattern has been on long-term loan to The Metropolitan Museum of Art since 1988.

2017.82

Creator
Made by Fulda Manufactory (German)
Object Title
Figure of Harlequin
Measurements
14.9 cm (5 7/8 in.) h.
Credit Line
Kiyi and Edward M. Pflueger Collection. Bequest of Edward M. Pflueger and Gift of Kiyi Powers Pflueger, from the Estate of Emma Lazarus Budge
Creation Date
about 1765
Object Type
Object URL
http://www.mfa.org/collections/object/figure-of-harlequin-466336

Claim Resolution

Resolution
Agreement reached, museum retained work
Resolution Date
March 1, 2017
Details of Resolution
In March 2017, the Museum of Fine Arts reached an agreement with the Estate of Emma Budge, allowing the Museum to retain seven pieces of 18th century German porcelain that were sold in Berlin in 1937.

The commedia dell’arte figures, made by the porcelain manufactories Höchst, Fürstenburg, and Fulda, all belonged to Emma Lazarus Budge (1852 – 1937), who built a large collection of decorative arts in her home in Hamburg. Upon her death in 1937, she left the disposition of her art collection to her estate executors, specifying that she did not wish the collection to be sold within National Socialist Germany. Mrs. Budge and all of her estate executors were Jewish.

Nevertheless, on October 4-6, 1937, a large portion of Emma Budge’s art collection was auctioned in Berlin. The proceeds from the sale were very probably credited to the account of the Budge estate at M. M. Warburg Bank in Hamburg. The settlement of the estate, however, was delayed until 1939. In the meantime, Warburg Bank was Aryanized, or sold to non-Jewish owners. Several of Mrs. Budge’s estate executors were dismissed from their roles. Many of her heirs, who were Jewish, fled Germany. Those who remained were subject to persecution. The estate funds that were ultimately disbursed were placed into tightly-controlled, blocked accounts to which the heirs did not have full access. Thus, as the direct result of Nazi persecution, the proceeds from the sale were never realized.

The seven pieces of porcelain at the MFA were purchased at the 1937 auction by Otto and Magdalena Blohm, likewise porcelain collectors from Hamburg, and probably acquaintances of Emma Budge. Mrs. Blohm moved to New York after World War II, bringing the porcelain collection with her. Edward and Kiyi Pflueger acquired the figures from the Blohm collection and bequeathed them to the MFA in 2006.

2017.81

Creator
Fürstenberg Manufactory (Germany), Modeled by Simon Feilner (1726–1798)
Object Title
Figure of Columbine
Measurements
19.4 cm (7 5/8 in.) h.
Credit Line
Kiyi and Edward M. Pflueger Collection. Bequest of Edward M. Pflueger and Gift of Kiyi Powers Pflueger, from the Estate of Emma Lazarus Budge
Creation Date
about 1754
Object Type
Object URL
http://www.mfa.org/collections/object/figure-of-columbine-466199

Claim Resolution

Resolution
Agreement reached, museum retained work
Resolution Date
March 1, 2017
Details of Resolution
In March 2017, the Museum of Fine Arts reached an agreement with the Estate of Emma Budge, allowing the Museum to retain seven pieces of 18th century German porcelain that were sold in Berlin in 1937.

The commedia dell’arte figures, made by the porcelain manufactories Höchst, Fürstenburg, and Fulda, all belonged to Emma Lazarus Budge (1852 – 1937), who built a large collection of decorative arts in her home in Hamburg. Upon her death in 1937, she left the disposition of her art collection to her estate executors, specifying that she did not wish the collection to be sold within National Socialist Germany. Mrs. Budge and all of her estate executors were Jewish.

Nevertheless, on October 4-6, 1937, a large portion of Emma Budge’s art collection was auctioned in Berlin. The proceeds from the sale were very probably credited to the account of the Budge estate at M. M. Warburg Bank in Hamburg. The settlement of the estate, however, was delayed until 1939. In the meantime, Warburg Bank was Aryanized, or sold to non-Jewish owners. Several of Mrs. Budge’s estate executors were dismissed from their roles. Many of her heirs, who were Jewish, fled Germany. Those who remained were subject to persecution. The estate funds that were ultimately disbursed were placed into tightly-controlled, blocked accounts to which the heirs did not have full access. Thus, as the direct result of Nazi persecution, the proceeds from the sale were never realized.

The seven pieces of porcelain at the MFA were purchased at the 1937 auction by Otto and Magdalena Blohm, likewise porcelain collectors from Hamburg, and probably acquaintances of Emma Budge. Mrs. Blohm moved to New York after World War II, bringing the porcelain collection with her. Edward and Kiyi Pflueger acquired the figures from the Blohm collection and bequeathed them to the MFA in 2006.
Subscribe to Ceramics